Berta Joncus is in awe of Harry Bicket and The English Concert’s excellent Serse
OPERA CHOICE
Handel
Serse Emily D’Angelo, Lucy Crowe, Paula Murrihy, Mary Bevan, Neal Davies; The English Concert/Harry Bicket Linn Records CKD709 172:38 mins (3 discs)
With his ravishing, hilarious and profound recording of Serse, conductor Harry Bicket once again puts all rivals in the shade. Handel re-invented pastiche in this genre-busting 1738 work, heightening satire with virtuosity and spinning ‘borrowed’ melodies – mostly from the 1694 Il Xerse by his early career rival Giovanni Bononcini – to show off his own dazzling invention.
As Romilda, soprano Lucy Crowe is a prodigy both technical – can any singer match her improbable dance in the vocal stratosphere? – and dramatic. Buffeted by the unwanted desire of the tyrant Serse and the jealousy of his sister Atalanta, who desires Romilda’s lover Arsamene, Crowe’s Romilda runs the affective gamut between tragedy and silliness. As Serse, mezzo-soprano Emily D’Angelo’s force-of-nature vocalism is tempered with fine acting; we hear Serse’s violence not just when it boils over, but even simmering under the serene ‘Ombra mai fu’. Soprano Mary Bevan brings a magnificent sweep to Atalanta, from the honeyed tone of her amorous numbers to the edgy bitterness of her final aria. The other soloists are all outstanding, getting this opera’s mix of comedy and seriousness just right, as when mezzo-soprano Paula Murrihy tinges Arsamene’s complaints with self-pity, or the baritone William Dazeley reveals vulnerability behind the klutziness of the manservant Elviro. The suave assurance of Bicket and the English Concert is expressed in gracious tempos, translucent textures and poetic continuo realisations, which also send up the emotional incontinence of the characters on stage. In all, a riveting performance.
PERFORMANCE
RECORDING
You can access thousands of reviews from our extensive archive on the BBC Music Magazine website at www.classical-music.com
Franck
Hulda
Jennifer Holloway, François Rougier, Véronique Gens, Judith van Wanroij, Edgaras Montvidas, Marie Gautrot, Matthieu Lécroart; Orchestre Philharmonique Royal de Liège; Chœur de Chambre de Namur/ Gergely Madaras
Bru Zane BZ 1052 156:10 mins (3 discs)
César Franck meets Wagner by way of Grieg in this splendid opera, presented here by the Palazzetto Bru Zane centre for French Romantic music. This is the second recording of Hulda – a five-act version was issued by Naxos in 2021. Here, Bru Zane presents the opera in four act
